Manhattan Parks Commissioner Tricia Shimamura took a hand in the Rivington Playground redesign and got us a section of our park back!!
Thank you to Ricardo Hinkle and Chris Crowley were on hand at the CB3 Parks meeting to run through the new additions to seating etc.
Thanks to the CB3 Committee and all the M’Finda Kalunga Gardeners who came out in support of the project: MKG Founders Bob Humber and Jim Pender, Co-Chairs Debra Jeffreys-Glass and Shweta Patwardhan, Architect Jennifer Carpenter. Angela Wai and Yaliza Hernandez (University Settlement Children’s programming) weighed in prior.
It’s good to see this entire park space being returned to the neighborhood/public as Park space!!!
Removable bollards, Increased seating – terrific.
The concrete chess tables – terrific.
Two child-sized picnic tables adjacent to one with accessible and/or adult seating.
And it appears that all the ’separate adults without children’ seating has been moved out of the playground. Great!
Parks will consider a request to add a ping pong table.
Will pull back benches adjacent to playground (so they can’t be used to climb over the fence after hours)
City-bike stand will remain in the area but on the adjacent new plaza on Forsyth street
Community will likely continue to request planters (which they would maintain)
Take a look:
Prior Quibbles and a few issues:
Issue that stands out: benches alongside the playground fence (it would be the same – even more complication- if they were alongside the MKGarden a dense garden area). Smoking dope on benches outside – past issue. Any fence/chairs have been/will be used to climb over fences. (resolved!)
If possible to remove those – put three-five benches back? One in between tree pits and two on the eastern side (or four if they faces each other)?
The tables/chair set up were well-used the last time but were broken quickly (trying to use them to climb over the fences).
Community will likely request planter boxes (at least at beginning and end northern seating area side to not interfere with bollards) to reorient the public and send the message?: This is a park are!
Background:
–CB3’s current reso on Rivington Playground
–Compilation of feedback SRPCC collected on Rivington Playground redesign (1st and most recent)
-Below CB3’s resolution (Sept 2024) most recent I believe:
- Parks: Proposed plan for renovation of the Rivington Street Playground (SDR Park)
TITLE: Support For The Rivington Street Playground Reconstruction Design
WHEREAS, Sara D. Roosevelt Park Rivington Street Playground, located in the Lower East Side
Between Forsyth Street and Chrystie Street, will be reconstructed; and
WHEREAS, the proposed design says that the playground will include the following elements: § Inclusive and state-of-the-art play units, swings, and water play
§ Improved access, circulation, and sightlines
§ Improved and upgraded seating
- Enhanced planting and permeability
§ Upgraded water service, drainage, and lighting, so
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that CB3 supports the proposed Rivington Street Playground design with the following conditions:
§ The fence remains at the current 7′ height
§ A larger slide is provided for the 5-12 play area
- The fence on the Forsyth St side is adjusted to create space for adult/multi-generational seating on the outside of the playground.
SRP Community Coalition Requests:
Mitigations/Requests for Rivington Transverse/Playground ( Most Relevant)
– Move the City-bike stand to adjacent Forsyth street. Activates the area – safer but it takes up park space in the narrow Rivington transverse that functions as a pathway to the garden and the playground. AND we have a drug dealer who deals, sitting on the bikes.
– Create mitigations to prevent cars, motorcycles, skateboarders from using Rivington transverse. Planters installed as traffic calming measures – install one or two tables and chairs in the center (similar to what is planned at Broome transverse?)
– Please! NO benches alongside the playground or garden – people use them to climb over the fences or smoke and it wafts into those spaces.
– Downward facing, brighter lighting, in the playground and on Rivington streetway, as a deterrent (downward facing to not disturb residents or birds).
– A needle disposal receptacle alongside MKGarden was requested by the Garden.
– Add large signage that includes:
No adults without children allowed – Include the fine.
No dogs in the playground. Include the fine for dogs off-leash.
As we said in the design scoping meeting – conferring with Bob (who sits out on Rivington almost daily) and University Settlement’s Childcare programming, MKG parents, and others who frequently use this playground:
-Move the high outer east side fence to separate the ‘adults with children’ section. The new fence location would align with the right side of the gate opening (as gate is now) – a straight line running north/south to enclose the playground area that is only for adults with children. And signage that states that.
-Create a separate, now wider, area on the East side of that ‘new’ high fence to create a larger seating area outside of the ‘new’ fence where adults and others can sit both during and after playground hours. Use planters to create a garden feel. Have that area brightly lit to deter unwanted activity.
– More downward facing lighting, in the playground, as a deterrent.
-The new design will no longer has adult’s (without children) seating INSIDE the playground (which had invited adults without children to use this space (as they do now). Parents/daycare staff safer without!
– A decent sized space alongside the playground would allow University Settlement staff, local residents, bike delivery people, our elders, and the public to use that adult seating area to relax, have lunch, and make the park area safer without risking getting ticketed or impinging on children’s safe space.
– It would end the perception and the reality of adult’s without children misusing the playground and permit the police or PEP to insist that adults without children leave that area. But encourage adults who need a space to sit in to use the area (possibly creating greater safety).
– Please leave the city-bike stand close by on Forsyth (but not in the transverse)!– its constant use makes the park safer.
– Create mitigations to prevent cars, motorcycles or skateboarders from misusing Rivington Streetway with ‘traffic calming measures’ to slow bikes and create an area for pedestrians only.
– PEP officer seated in the Rivington area.
– We’ve had a request for a needle disposal box near the MKGarden to prevent needles being thrown into the Garden edges.
– The Rivington lights are still not working. Dangerous area.
Full Compilation of current situation and feedback collected by SRPCC on Rivington Playground redesign
SRPCC/MKG Situation:
A number of adults without children who use, and some who misuse, the Rivington Playground.
Misuse in the Playground:
Construction workers/others smoking cannabis. People in distress and others dumping trash, leaving used needles, engaging in sex, shooting up, using it as a latrine, dog owners bringing dogs in off-leash/leaving dog droppings, or other behaviors/acts that aren’t conducive to a children’s playground.
We have teens/adults using the playground if/when it isn’t locked after hours.
Over a year ago, neighbors let us know that a number of 13-year-olds managed to get into this playground area at night – and apparently with guns on them (neighbors said they were not from around here).
Misuse in the Rivington Transverse:
Skateboarders had regularly used the Rivington streetway to ‘practice’ – are threatening to pedestrians.
We’ve had someone dealing on the bikes – across from the playground/MKGarden
Some locals are not willing to call the police, given the sense that our precinct is no longer functioning with the concept of community policing – due to concerns for their own children’s safety.
Bike riders/skateboarders sometimes even cars/trucks drive through here – children run back and forth from the M’Finda garden to the playground across the Rivington Streetway on weekends in particular – not tenable.
Adults without children simply being in the playground:
Some adults without children, simply sit inside, using it as an open space which contributes to the safety of the entire area – and their own.
The playground is used by nearby staff from local small businesses and University Settlement, and now Mount Sinai’s Behavioral Center, construction workers or tourists. Many of those living in shelter nearby are simply needing a shaded place to sit – like the others. Residents who use this area of the park: for lunch, to enjoy the outdoors, to read, meet up with other workers in the neighborhood (construction/bike messengers), tourists, small business workers, general public, teenagers for after-school hangout (4 high schools a block from here) when the playground is often closed (or should be).
After the First Design Meeting on Zoom
After the design meeting at CB3 parks committee we conferred with Bob Humber (who sits on Rivington almost daily in the warmer months), University Settlement’s Jennifer Vallone and their Day Care staff, MKGardeners, teenagers from the local high schools, local residents, local businesses, MKGarden parents, and parents who frequently use this playground, and adults without children.
What we heard:
Positive notes
The funding for this!
The design is lovely for the children.
It creates two spaces for different ages.
The additional trees are wonderful. Shade is going to be more and more important.
In the summer, a free breakfast and lunch truck distributes for children under 18 years old. (though it no longer draws as many children to this section due to what goes there).
Thanks to the immediate response from Parks’ Ralph Musolino, who removed a broken pipe the skateboarders are no longer practicing on Rivington transverse.
Parks staff, Park Manager Jamil, work very hard to keep this area clean.
Bob Humber still sits and monitors the area.
Requests:
Playground design kept as is but…
Create a larger space on the Forsyth Side to accommodate the many non-senior, non-parent adults, general public and residents. (detailed suggestions below)
Advantages:
Children with caregivers/parents have a dedicated playground space – not competing with other adult’s need for space.
An area for adults without children and teenagers is available both during and after playground hours.
Adult seating area sizable enough to relax, have lunch, and make the park area safer without risking getting ticketed or harassed. Makes the area safer by their presence.
The police/PEP need the signage to remove adults without children from the playground. Separating usage and signage for the playground provides police/PEP with a deterrent to misuse. They are allowed to remove adults from the playground without needing to wait until someone misuses it (and discourages profiling as determining factors). Police have told us time and again that they need that sign.
Creating an Enlarged Adult Seating Area Proposal:
– Move the 7’ (outer east side playground fence) to enlarge the adults (without children) seating area outside of the Playground along the Forsyth Street side.
– The new fence location could align with the right side of the current gate opening – a straight line running north/south.
– Or create a larger adult seating space in the Northeast corner.
– Enclose the cement chess tables that are in this area for adult’s lunch or chess.
– Planters alongside the playground’s Forsyth (East) side to create a garden feel and to buffer the children’s playground from adults using the seating – face benches away from playground sightlines.
– Add picnic tables and benches with backs.
– A water spigot in adult area.